Loading goals…
hockeygamebot
← Articles

HGB Research

The price of a penalty

The average two-minute penalty costs 3.3% of a win (2.2% in the last 2:20 of a period). Tied late in the third period, it costs 8–10%. We priced 47,909 regulation minor penalties that created a power play, 2018-19 to 2025-26, by the score, period and time they were taken.

By Matt Donders5 min read

The average two-minute penalty costs the penalized team 3.3% of a win. Penalties in the last 2:20 of a period are priced separately and average 2.2%. On average, a team at 50% to win drops to about 46.7%.

A hook in the first period of a 4-1 game and a hook with five minutes left in a tie put the same power play on the ice. The second one costs more, because a single goal decides more of the result when the game is close and the clock is short. So we measured penalties by their effect on win probability, not just by goals. ”% of a win” below means percentage points of win probability.

The average penalty: 3.3% of a win

We looked at 42,471 two-minute penalties from 2018-19 through 2025-26 that put a team on the power play with more than 2:20 left in the period. Another 5,438 came in the last 2:20 of a period. Those are priced on their own late-period line, and they’re included in the team and player totals below. For each one we compared the 2:20 after the call, even if a power-play goal ended the penalty early, with ordinary five-on-five stretches of the same length, in the same score, period and five-minute stretch of the period.

  • The penalized team ends up 0.20 goals worse off than at five-on-five (95% range 0.198–0.208).
  • It gives up 0.225 power-play goals per penalty and scores 0.029 short-handed goals back. Other goals in the window, after the power play ends, make up the small rest.
  • In win probability, a penalty costs 3.3% of a win (3.25–3.44). That’s about one win for every 30 penalties.

3.3%

of a win, the cost of an average penalty

n = 42,471 · 95% 3.25–3.44%

30

penalties, about one win

from the average cost

8–10%

of a win, tied in the third from 10:00 to 17:40

see the period and minute chart

As a check, the method gives 0.2255 power-play goals per penalty. Counted the same way, per two-minute penalty rather than per official power-play opportunity, the league rate over the same seasons is 0.2216.

Cost of a penalty, by score

n2%4%6%Cost, % of a winDown 2+: 1.1% of a win (95% range 1.0% to 1.3%), n = 5,5891.1%Down 2+5,589Down 1: 3.6% of a win (95% range 3.4% to 3.8%), n = 6,9873.6%Down 16,987Tied: 4.4% of a win (95% range 4.2% to 4.6%), n = 14,2324.4%Tied14,232Up 1: 4.2% of a win (95% range 4.0% to 4.5%), n = 8,4814.2%Up 18,481Up 2+: 1.7% of a win (95% range 1.6% to 1.9%), n = 7,1821.7%Up 2+7,1822%4%6%Cost, % of a winDown 2+: 1.1% of a win (95% range 1.0% to 1.3%), n = 5,5891.1%Down 2+n=5,589Down 1: 3.6% of a win (95% range 3.4% to 3.8%), n = 6,9873.6%Down 1n=6,987Tied: 4.4% of a win (95% range 4.2% to 4.6%), n = 14,2324.4%Tiedn=14,232Up 1: 4.2% of a win (95% range 4.0% to 4.5%), n = 8,4814.2%Up 1n=8,481Up 2+: 1.7% of a win (95% range 1.6% to 1.9%), n = 7,1821.7%Up 2+n=7,182

Cost to the penalized team, in % of a win, over the 2:20 after the call, against matched five-on-five stretches in the same score, period, minute and venue. Score is from the penalized team's side.

Source: HGB analysis of NHL play-by-play, regular seasons 2018-19 to 2025-26 (9,781 games). Thin lines and bands: 95% ranges.

Show the numbers
Score (penalized team)Cost, % of a win95% rangeMinor penalties
Down 2+1.1%1.0% to 1.3%5,589
Down 13.6%3.4% to 3.8%6,987
Tied4.4%4.2% to 4.6%14,232
Up 14.2%4.0% to 4.5%8,481
Up 2+1.7%1.6% to 1.9%7,182

The score changes what a goal is worth

The power play does about the same damage in every score state: the penalized team ends up about 0.20 goals worse off each time. What changes is how much one goal moves the result.

Penalized teamMinor penaltiesCost per penalty
Tied14,2324.4%
Up 18,4814.2%
Down 16,9873.6%
Up 2 or more7,1821.7%
Down 2 or more5,5891.1%

Up one, a power-play goal against ties the game. Down one, it turns a deficit the team was already likely to lose into a two-goal hole, so it moves the result a little less. With a lead or deficit of at least two, a single goal rarely changes who wins, and a penalty costs a quarter to two-fifths of what it costs in a tie.

Tied games: the cost climbs through the third

Tied in the first period, a penalty costs about 3.5%. Tied in the third, it costs 6.4% in the first five minutes (746 penalties), 8.2% from 10:00 to 15:00 (549) and 10.3% from 15:00 to 17:40 (259). The late samples are smaller, so their ranges are wider and overlap (see the chart).

Cost of a penalty, by period and minute

  • Tied (shaded: 95% range)
  • Up 1
  • Down 1
5%10%15%Cost, % of a win1st2nd3rdTied, 1st period 0:00–5:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 3.0% to 3.7%), n = 2,610Tied, 1st period 5:00–10:00: 3.6% of a win (95% range 3.2% to 4.0%), n = 2,206Tied, 1st period 10:00–15:00: 3.5% of a win (95% range 3.1% to 3.9%), n = 1,908Tied, 1st period 15:00–17:40: 3.6% of a win (95% range 3.0% to 4.3%), n = 926Tied, 2nd period 0:00–5:00: 4.2% of a win (95% range 3.6% to 4.8%), n = 1,315Tied, 2nd period 5:00–10:00: 4.1% of a win (95% range 3.5% to 4.8%), n = 1,317Tied, 2nd period 10:00–15:00: 4.5% of a win (95% range 3.8% to 5.2%), n = 1,079Tied, 2nd period 15:00–17:40: 3.9% of a win (95% range 2.7% to 5.0%), n = 619Tied, 3rd period 0:00–5:00: 6.4% of a win (95% range 5.4% to 7.4%), n = 746Tied, 3rd period 5:00–10:00: 7.8% of a win (95% range 6.6% to 9.0%), n = 698Tied, 3rd period 10:00–15:00: 8.2% of a win (95% range 6.6% to 9.8%), n = 549Tied, 3rd period 15:00–17:40: 10.3% of a win (95% range 7.4% to 13.3%), n = 259Up 1, 1st period 0:00–5:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.4% to 4.4%), n = 270Up 1, 1st period 5:00–10:00: 3.3% of a win (95% range 2.7% to 3.9%), n = 809Up 1, 1st period 10:00–15:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.8% to 4.0%), n = 978Up 1, 1st period 15:00–17:40: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.6% to 4.3%), n = 570Up 1, 2nd period 0:00–5:00: 4.1% of a win (95% range 3.4% to 4.8%), n = 958Up 1, 2nd period 5:00–10:00: 3.7% of a win (95% range 3.0% to 4.6%), n = 1,041Up 1, 2nd period 10:00–15:00: 4.6% of a win (95% range 3.8% to 5.3%), n = 1,024Up 1, 2nd period 15:00–17:40: 3.1% of a win (95% range 2.1% to 4.1%), n = 511Up 1, 3rd period 0:00–5:00: 6.0% of a win (95% range 4.9% to 7.2%), n = 703Up 1, 3rd period 5:00–10:00: 5.2% of a win (95% range 3.9% to 6.4%), n = 713Up 1, 3rd period 10:00–15:00: 5.7% of a win (95% range 4.2% to 7.1%), n = 631Up 1, 3rd period 15:00–17:40: 5.9% of a win (95% range 3.4% to 8.3%), n = 273Down 1, 1st period 0:00–5:00: 3.5% of a win (95% range 2.5% to 4.4%), n = 267Down 1, 1st period 5:00–10:00: 3.1% of a win (95% range 2.4% to 3.7%), n = 597Down 1, 1st period 10:00–15:00: 3.2% of a win (95% range 2.7% to 3.7%), n = 828Down 1, 1st period 15:00–17:40: 4.3% of a win (95% range 3.6% to 5.1%), n = 453Down 1, 2nd period 0:00–5:00: 3.3% of a win (95% range 2.7% to 3.9%), n = 853Down 1, 2nd period 5:00–10:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.8% to 4.0%), n = 938Down 1, 2nd period 10:00–15:00: 3.7% of a win (95% range 3.2% to 4.4%), n = 837Down 1, 2nd period 15:00–17:40: 3.9% of a win (95% range 3.1% to 4.9%), n = 416Down 1, 3rd period 0:00–5:00: 4.3% of a win (95% range 3.4% to 5.1%), n = 564Down 1, 3rd period 5:00–10:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.5% to 4.2%), n = 541Down 1, 3rd period 10:00–15:00: 3.2% of a win (95% range 2.3% to 4.0%), n = 518Down 1, 3rd period 15:00–17:40: 4.9% of a win (95% range 3.6% to 5.8%), n = 175TiedUp 1Down 15%10%15%Cost, % of a win1st2nd3rdTied, 1st period 0:00–5:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 3.0% to 3.7%), n = 2,610Tied, 1st period 5:00–10:00: 3.6% of a win (95% range 3.2% to 4.0%), n = 2,206Tied, 1st period 10:00–15:00: 3.5% of a win (95% range 3.1% to 3.9%), n = 1,908Tied, 1st period 15:00–17:40: 3.6% of a win (95% range 3.0% to 4.3%), n = 926Tied, 2nd period 0:00–5:00: 4.2% of a win (95% range 3.6% to 4.8%), n = 1,315Tied, 2nd period 5:00–10:00: 4.1% of a win (95% range 3.5% to 4.8%), n = 1,317Tied, 2nd period 10:00–15:00: 4.5% of a win (95% range 3.8% to 5.2%), n = 1,079Tied, 2nd period 15:00–17:40: 3.9% of a win (95% range 2.7% to 5.0%), n = 619Tied, 3rd period 0:00–5:00: 6.4% of a win (95% range 5.4% to 7.4%), n = 746Tied, 3rd period 5:00–10:00: 7.8% of a win (95% range 6.6% to 9.0%), n = 698Tied, 3rd period 10:00–15:00: 8.2% of a win (95% range 6.6% to 9.8%), n = 549Tied, 3rd period 15:00–17:40: 10.3% of a win (95% range 7.4% to 13.3%), n = 259Up 1, 1st period 0:00–5:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.4% to 4.4%), n = 270Up 1, 1st period 5:00–10:00: 3.3% of a win (95% range 2.7% to 3.9%), n = 809Up 1, 1st period 10:00–15:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.8% to 4.0%), n = 978Up 1, 1st period 15:00–17:40: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.6% to 4.3%), n = 570Up 1, 2nd period 0:00–5:00: 4.1% of a win (95% range 3.4% to 4.8%), n = 958Up 1, 2nd period 5:00–10:00: 3.7% of a win (95% range 3.0% to 4.6%), n = 1,041Up 1, 2nd period 10:00–15:00: 4.6% of a win (95% range 3.8% to 5.3%), n = 1,024Up 1, 2nd period 15:00–17:40: 3.1% of a win (95% range 2.1% to 4.1%), n = 511Up 1, 3rd period 0:00–5:00: 6.0% of a win (95% range 4.9% to 7.2%), n = 703Up 1, 3rd period 5:00–10:00: 5.2% of a win (95% range 3.9% to 6.4%), n = 713Up 1, 3rd period 10:00–15:00: 5.7% of a win (95% range 4.2% to 7.1%), n = 631Up 1, 3rd period 15:00–17:40: 5.9% of a win (95% range 3.4% to 8.3%), n = 273Down 1, 1st period 0:00–5:00: 3.5% of a win (95% range 2.5% to 4.4%), n = 267Down 1, 1st period 5:00–10:00: 3.1% of a win (95% range 2.4% to 3.7%), n = 597Down 1, 1st period 10:00–15:00: 3.2% of a win (95% range 2.7% to 3.7%), n = 828Down 1, 1st period 15:00–17:40: 4.3% of a win (95% range 3.6% to 5.1%), n = 453Down 1, 2nd period 0:00–5:00: 3.3% of a win (95% range 2.7% to 3.9%), n = 853Down 1, 2nd period 5:00–10:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.8% to 4.0%), n = 938Down 1, 2nd period 10:00–15:00: 3.7% of a win (95% range 3.2% to 4.4%), n = 837Down 1, 2nd period 15:00–17:40: 3.9% of a win (95% range 3.1% to 4.9%), n = 416Down 1, 3rd period 0:00–5:00: 4.3% of a win (95% range 3.4% to 5.1%), n = 564Down 1, 3rd period 5:00–10:00: 3.4% of a win (95% range 2.5% to 4.2%), n = 541Down 1, 3rd period 10:00–15:00: 3.2% of a win (95% range 2.3% to 4.0%), n = 518Down 1, 3rd period 15:00–17:40: 4.9% of a win (95% range 3.6% to 5.8%), n = 175TiedUp 1Down 1

Each point is a five-minute stretch of a period. The last runs 15:00–17:40, because penalties with under 2:20 left are priced on their own late-period line.

Source: HGB analysis of NHL play-by-play, regular seasons 2018-19 to 2025-26 (9,781 games). Thin lines and bands: 95% ranges.

Show the numbers
Period, minuteTiedUp 1Down 1Tied 95% rangeTied n
P1 0:00–5:003.4%3.4%3.5%3.0% to 3.7%2,610
P1 5:00–10:003.6%3.3%3.1%3.2% to 4.0%2,206
P1 10:00–15:003.5%3.4%3.2%3.1% to 3.9%1,908
P1 15:00–17:403.6%3.4%4.3%3.0% to 4.3%926
P2 0:00–5:004.2%4.1%3.3%3.6% to 4.8%1,315
P2 5:00–10:004.1%3.7%3.4%3.5% to 4.8%1,317
P2 10:00–15:004.5%4.6%3.7%3.8% to 5.2%1,079
P2 15:00–17:403.9%3.1%3.9%2.7% to 5.0%619
P3 0:00–5:006.4%6.0%4.3%5.4% to 7.4%746
P3 5:00–10:007.8%5.2%3.4%6.6% to 9.0%698
P3 10:00–15:008.2%5.7%3.2%6.6% to 9.8%549
P3 15:00–17:4010.3%5.9%4.9%7.4% to 13.3%259

Who takes the penalty: no clear difference

We tested whether a penalty costs more when the player who took it is one of his team’s regular penalty killers, since he can’t kill his own penalty. Across 40,578 penalties we added two measures for each taker, both from earlier games: his share of his team’s penalty-kill (PK) minutes, and the chances the PK allowed with him on the ice. Neither showed a clear association with what the power play produced. More than half the takers had little PK history, which limits how finely this can be measured.

Team by team, 2025-26

Here each penalty is priced at the state it was taken in: score, period and five-minute stretch. Penalties in the last 2:20 of a period use a late-period price that varies by period only. That gives every team an expected cost for the penalties it took and an expected gain for the ones it drew. These are expected values for the game state, not what happened on each power play.

  • Minnesota was priced at +1.7 wins (95% range +0.7 to +2.8 wins). It drew 216 penalties and took 169.
  • Toronto was at −1.3 wins (−2.4 to −0.3). It took 200 and drew 160. The Rangers were at −1.1 (−2.2 to −0.04), just short of zero.
  • For the other 29 teams, the gap is too small to call either way. These ranges count only which penalties each team took and drew; the price of each game state is held fixed, which keeps them narrow. With 32 teams, one or two would land outside zero by chance alone, so this table describes the season. It doesn’t rank discipline as a skill.
2025-26: what penalties cost each team, in expected wins
TeamTakenDrawnExp. wins lostExp. wins gainedNet95% range
Minnesota Wild1692165.667.38+1.72+0.7 to +2.8
Washington Capitals2041996.026.91+0.90−0.2 to +1.9
Chicago Blackhawks1901986.437.20+0.77−0.4 to +1.9
Detroit Red Wings1822166.447.01+0.57−0.5 to +1.7
Anaheim Ducks2092246.907.42+0.52−0.7 to +1.7
Vancouver Canucks1941975.976.49+0.51−0.3 to +1.4
New York Islanders1851936.106.59+0.49−0.7 to +1.7
Buffalo Sabres1902036.456.89+0.45−0.7 to +1.7
Carolina Hurricanes1941996.156.58+0.43−0.6 to +1.5
Vegas Golden Knights1691885.345.76+0.43−0.6 to +1.5
Calgary Flames1962006.446.83+0.39−0.8 to +1.6
Dallas Stars2062097.117.43+0.32−0.9 to +1.5
New Jersey Devils1681725.836.08+0.25−0.8 to +1.2
San Jose Sharks2132156.806.93+0.12−1.0 to +1.2
Seattle Kraken1781825.745.77+0.03−1.1 to +1.1
Ottawa Senators2022166.596.62+0.03−0.9 to +1.0
Edmonton Oilers1821845.925.93+0.01−1.0 to +1.1
Winnipeg Jets1941866.306.24−0.06−1.2 to +1.0
St. Louis Blues1721765.555.48−0.07−1.0 to +0.9
Boston Bruins2282107.337.20−0.13−1.5 to +1.2
Columbus Blue Jackets1851615.835.57−0.25−1.4 to +1.0
Montreal Canadiens2032016.936.65−0.27−1.4 to +0.9
Florida Panthers2252107.387.11−0.28−1.5 to +0.9
Los Angeles Kings1881896.996.68−0.30−1.6 to +1.0
Utah Mammoth2051976.666.15−0.51−1.5 to +0.5
Tampa Bay Lightning1981996.756.23−0.51−1.7 to +0.5
Philadelphia Flyers1981956.756.05−0.70−1.8 to +0.4
Pittsburgh Penguins2041866.375.62−0.75−1.7 to +0.3
Colorado Avalanche2142227.386.61−0.77−1.8 to +0.3
Nashville Predators2101947.236.29−0.94−2.0 to +0.1
New York Rangers2121706.765.66−1.09−2.2 to −0.04
Toronto Maple Leafs2001606.405.09−1.30−2.4 to −0.3

Expected values for the game state each penalty was taken in, not what happened on each power play. Net = gained minus lost. Ranges resample whole games and treat the per-state prices as fixed. Sorted by net; teams named above are highlighted.

Source: HGB analysis of NHL play-by-play. Expected wins, priced by score, period and time of each penalty.

Every team and season, 2018-19 to 2025-26 →

Players

Player figures are model-based expected values, with no ranges. About 9% of penalties have no recorded player who drew them, so “drawn” and net totals run slightly low.

  • Connor McDavid holds four of the five best player-seasons by net since 2018-19. In 2025-26 he drew 36 penalties and took 14.
  • Josh Manson (COL, 2025-26) took 30 penalties priced at 1.0 expected wins, narrowly the most of any player-season since 2018-19 (Svechnikov 2021-22 and Zadorov 2024-25 are at 0.96). Each of his penalties cost about the league average; the total comes from volume.
  • Timing moves the bill. 49% of the expected cost of Ben Chiarot’s 20 penalties in 2025-26 came in the third period of one-goal or tied games. Across the league that season, the share was 26%.
Costliest player-seasons since 2018-19 (min. 10 penalties taken)
PlayerTeamSeasonTakenExp. wins lostHigh-leverage shareNet
Josh MansonCOL2025-26301.0134%−0.81
Andrei SvechnikovCAR2021-22260.9622%−0.36
Nikita ZadorovBOS2024-25320.9620%−0.61
Lars EllerWSH2019-20210.9245%−0.48
Radko GudasFLA2022-23230.9241%−0.75
Ian ColeUTA2024-25300.9117%−0.72
Vincent TrocheckNYR2022-23220.9136%−0.53
Nikita ZadorovBOS2025-26280.8917%−0.51
Vladislav GavrikovCBJ2021-22220.8745%−0.69
Tanner JeannotNSH2021-22200.8745%−0.60

Model-based expected wins, no ranges. High-leverage share: part of the expected cost that came in the third period of one-goal or tied games. Net runs slightly low: some drawn penalties have no recorded player.

Source: HGB analysis of NHL play-by-play. Expected wins, priced by score, period and time of each penalty.

Best player-seasons by net (taken + drawn ≥ 10)
PlayerTeamSeasonDrawnTakenNet
Connor McDavidEDM2023-24348+1.04
Connor McDavidEDM2025-263614+0.93
Connor McDavidEDM2022-233513+0.89
Jeff SkinnerBUF2018-19309+0.86
Connor McDavidEDM2021-22419+0.85

Net = expected wins gained from penalties drawn minus wins lost to penalties taken. It runs slightly low, for the same reason.

Source: HGB analysis of NHL play-by-play. Expected wins, priced by score, period and time of each penalty.

Every player and season, 2018-19 to 2025-26 →